Gilshar Greek Cafe

Welcome to Gilshar Greek Cafe, a delightful culinary oasis located at 1072 NY-112, Port Jefferson Station, NY. If you’re seeking an authentic taste of Greece, this cozy restaurant should be at the top of your list. With its inviting atmosphere and passionate dedication to quality, every dining experience here feels like a warm embrace from the Mediterranean.

The menu at Gilshar is a celebration of Greek cuisine, featuring an enticing selection of appetizers, soups, salads, and hearty main dishes. Be sure to start your meal with their Spanakopita ($7.50), a deliciously flaky pastry filled with fresh spinach and feta, or indulge in their Bacon Wrapped Shrimp ($13.99)—a mouthwatering combination that pairs beautifully with their homemade tzatziki sauce. Not to be missed is the Cold Appetizer Platter ($12.00), a delightful sampling of hummus, dolmas, pita, and yogurt sauce that will transport your taste buds straight to Greece.

For those looking for something heartwarming, the Chicken Lemon Soup ($5.99) is a must-try; its rich flavor and comforting warmth make for the perfect companion to a busy day. If you’re seeking a refreshing crunch, the Greek Salad ($13.50) is praised for its vibrant ingredients and generous portion, a favorite among locals. As customer Izabella Halkas states, “the Greek salad is by far the best one I’ve had!”

The dining atmosphere is casual yet welcoming, with simple decor that reflects the charm of traditional Greek eateries. Many guests have commented on the friendly service, noting how the staff treats every visitor like family. As Shady Creek PammyC shared, “the service was spot on, and the flavors of the meat in my gyro were incredible.” It’s not just about the food here; it’s also about creating a memorable experience filled with genuine hospitality.

Whether you are dining in or opting for takeout, Gilshar Greek Cafe consistently delivers quality and satisfaction. Customer Brandon Bernard aptly sums it up: “the quality/quantity and price is unbeatable,” making it a gem in the local dining scene that has remained steadfast in its commitment to freshness and authenticity.

So why not treat yourself to a meal at Gilshar Greek Cafe? Enjoy the fresh, flavorful delights of Greek cuisine, and experience the warmth of genuine hospitality that has made this eatery a beloved choice for many. Don’t forget to call ahead at +1 631-473-2909 to make your experience even smoother. There’s a table waiting for you!

• Spanakopita

  US$7.50
• Hummus

  US$8.25
• Dolmas

  US$7.50
• Mozzarella Sticks

  US$7.25
• Pita & Yogurt

  US$4.50
• Cold Appetizer Platter

  US$12.00
• Bacon Wrapped Shrimp

  US$13.99

• Chicken Lemon

  US$5.99
• Spinach Lentil

  US$5.99

• Side

  US$6.99
• Small

  US$8.99
• Large

  US$13.50
• Hot Seeded Pita w/ Salad

  US$13.75
• Soup and Salad

  US$14.50